Cigar Review
One of the most decorated cigars ever rolled. We break down exactly what you taste, what you pay for, and whether it earns its reputation.
Most cigars at this price point promise a lot and deliver a range. The Padron 1964 Anniversary is different — it promises a benchmark experience and, smoke after smoke, it delivers one. But understanding why requires more than reading a score.
You have probably seen a 96 somewhere attached to this cigar. You have probably also paid $25 or more for a smoke that left you wondering what the fuss was about. The Padron 1964 Anniversary is not that cigar — but you need to know what to look for to get the full experience out of it.
Jose Orlando Padron launched the 1964 Anniversary Series in 1994 to mark 30 years of Padron Cigars. The line commemorates the year he founded the company — 1964 — after fleeing Cuba and resettling in Miami with little more than a craft and a reputation. The 1964 Anniversary is made entirely from Nicaraguan tobacco: aged four years minimum before rolling, sun-grown wrapper from Jalapa or Estelí, and a binder and filler from the same regions.
That four-year aging commitment matters. It removes harshness and sharp ammonia notes that plague younger Nicaraguan puros, and it produces the signature velvet-meets-pepper finish that has made this line a measuring stick for the entire premium category.
The Padron 1964 Anniversary arrives in a box-pressed format that is immediately tactile. The wrapper — available in Natural (colorado) and Maduro — is smooth to the touch, with minimal veins and an even, oily sheen that signals proper aging and humidity control. The seams are nearly invisible. The cap is clean and cuts easily with minimal risk of unraveling.
Before lighting, the cold draw reveals the profile ahead: natural sweetness, cedar, a faint cocoa note on the Maduro. The draw resistance is ideal — open enough to produce dense smoke without feeling loose or airy.
The opening is gentle compared to what most expect from a full Nicaraguan puro. Cedar leads, followed quickly by a creamy sweetness. There is pepper, but it stays in the background — present on the retrohale and finish rather than upfront on the palate. This is the product of the aging: no harshness, no raw tobacco sharpness. It is immediately approachable even to someone stepping up from a medium-bodied smoke.
This is where the cigar opens its full complexity. The cedar transitions into dark chocolate on the Maduro, or leather and dried fruit on the Natural. Coffee notes emerge — not bitter espresso, but a roasted, rounded coffee that pairs almost perfectly with a black pour. The pepper builds on the retrohale. Strength nudges from medium to medium-full without becoming dominant. The smoke production is dense and consistent.
The burn remains even to within an inch of the nub — a testament to the hand-rolled construction at the Padron factory in Nicaragua. Flavors intensify rather than turn harsh: dark chocolate and earth on the Maduro, spice and black pepper on the Natural. The finish is long, clean, and warm. You will remember it.
Aficionado Score
Both are exceptional, but they serve different occasions and palates. The Natural (Colorado) wrapper is sun-grown and produces a more complex, nuanced profile: leather, cedar, dried fruit, and a long spiced finish. It rewards attention. The Maduro wrapper is fermented longer, which converts more starches to sugars, producing a sweeter, rounder smoke with prominent dark chocolate and coffee notes. It is more forgiving as a daily smoke and pairs more easily with bourbon or coffee.
If you have never tried the line, start with the Maduro in a Exclusivo (robusto) size. If you want maximum complexity and you are already comfortable with full Nicaraguan tobacco, the Natural Torpedo rewards a slow, focused smoke session.
The Padron 1964 Anniversary is one of the most pairing-friendly cigars at its strength level. Its balanced profile does not compete aggressively with what you drink alongside it:
You can explore pairing recommendations for this and other cigars in the Cigar AI pairing engine.
The 1964 Anniversary sits in a tier alongside the Oliva Serie V Melanio, Perdomo Reserve Champagne, and Arturo Fuente Opus X — all cigars with significant aging, high construction standards, and price points that demand a verdict. Here is how it stands against the closest comparison:
Use the Cigar AI comparison tool to run a side-by-side on flavor profile, strength, and origin for any cigars you are considering.
The Padron 1964 Anniversary earns its reputation. It is not hype sustained by scarcity or brand loyalty — it is a cigar that consistently delivers a complex, even, and satisfying experience across every vitola in the line. The four-year aging protocol shows in the absence of harshness and the presence of layered flavor transitions that less patient producers cannot replicate.
At $22 to $35 depending on vitola and retailer, it is a genuine value in the context of what it delivers. It is not an everyday smoke for most — but it is the benchmark smoke that calibrates your palate for everything else you try.
View the full flavor profile and user ratings for the Padron 1964 Anniversary in the Cigar AI catalog.
Smokers with 6 or more months of regular premium cigar experience who want a reliable benchmark for the medium-full Nicaraguan puro category. Not a starting cigar — but an ideal second-level cigar for someone ready to move beyond mild-to-medium blends. Also a strong choice as a gift for an experienced aficionado.
Cigar AI identifies any cigar by photo, shows you the full flavor breakdown, and recommends your next smoke based on what you have already enjoyed. Free on iOS and Android.
Download Free — iOS & Android Or browse 1,583 cigars in the free catalog.