When to Buy a Box — and When Not To

The "box discount" is the most dangerous marketing tactic in the cigar world. Saving 10% on a box of 20 cigars you only "kind of" like is not a deal. It's a liability.

The Cost of Commitment

A box takes up space. It requires humidity maintenance. But most importantly, it represents 20 smoking opportunities. If you lock yourself into 20 mediocre experiences, you are opportunity-costing yourself out of discovering 20 potential favorites.

The 'Core Rotation' Rule

Only buy a box if the cigar fits into your "Core Rotation." A Core Rotation cigar must satisfy three criteria:

• Consistency: You have smoked at least 3, and they were identical in performance.
• Utility: You know exactly when you will smoke this (e.g., "This is my Friday morning coffee cigar").
• Aging Potential: You are okay with how this blend will taste in 3 years if you don't finish it fast.

When to Stick to Singles/Fives

If you are exploring a new brand, chasing a "limited edition" hype train, or experimenting with a wrapper you usually dislike—buy singles. The premium per stick is the price you pay for the freedom to pivot.

Use Cigar AI to track your re-smoke frequency. If the data shows you return to a blend more than 3 times in a quarter, you have permission to buy the box.

Track Your Re-Smoke Rates