Cigar AI Community

Cigar Notes From the Community

Explore real smoke logs from Cigar AI members—what they smoked, how it landed, and the details they chose to share.

233 active smoke logsRatings, notes, pairings, and photosFor adults 21+

Each card is one member's selected public experience, not an editorial review, catalog fact, or community average. Report content or request a rights review.

Casa Cuevas Maduro shared by Cigar AI member 7.0/10
Cigar AI memberMar 13, 2026
Casa Cuevas
Maduro

Nice semi oily cigar. Good flavor of black coffee and almost a bitter toffee note. Hard to explain. Construction could use a helping hand as this particular stick must have gotten a little too dry at some point. Humidor read 65 rh so who knows. Draw is slightly above average. Goes pretty well with this Guinness im drinking. I've had better but lord knows I've had worse.

Paired with GuinnessMedium-Full
Read smoke log →
Jorge's Cigars La Bella Isla shared by Cigar AI member 7.9/10
Cigar AI memberMar 13, 2026
Jorge's Cigars
La Bella Isla

Im pleasantly surprised by this stick. Chocolate immediately on dry pull and milk chocolate lit. Good even burn throughout. Above average draw ability. Bread crust/toast lingers a bit on the finish. Lightly sweet corojo wrapper gives it a nice touch. Definitely more medium than full but its nice. Id gladly smoke another 1 around breakfast

Paired with WineMedium
Read smoke log →
Crowned Heads La Imperiosa shared by Cigar AI member 8.9/10
Cigar AI memberMar 12, 2026
Crowned Heads
La Imperiosa

Now this is a damn good cigar! She's oily as hell and leather notes creep through instantly with a hint of expresso. Incredibly well made and the draw is perfection. Some toasted nuts with some char finish give it some back bone. I definitely would love to have this again after a nice medium/rare t-bone.

Paired with PilsnerFull
Read smoke log →
Punch Golden Era shared by Cigar AI member 7.4/10
Cigar AI memberMar 12, 2026
Punch
Golden Era

Good construction and good draw ability. Nice medium stick. Lots of toast and little bit of coffee. Nice even burn, no sweetness detected on the outter wrapper. To me, its better suited for a morning coffee type of cigar. Its good but doesn't blow my kilt up.

Paired with Red WineMedium-Full
Read smoke log →
Cao Amazon basin shared by Cigar AI member 8.5/10
Cigar AI memberMar 1, 2026
Cao
Amazon basin

good construction , 1/3 peperry 2/3 soft sweetness take slowly the place 3/3 the sweetness became lightly burn good experience and cigar overall was a little too on the ligth side would smome it again but not keep in my humidor .

Medium-Full
Read smoke log →
Matilde Serena Maduro shared by Cigar AI member 8.0/10
Cigar AI memberMar 1, 2026
Matilde
Serena Maduro

The main course here was leather. 1/3 the leather taste was lingering inside a faint white pepper taste. 2/3 the pepper hide himself to let graduelly a hint of burn coffe to mix with the leather founding 3/3 the leather is back with a little burning taste , and the coffe seem to satart a figth with it but is always pushed back , you can feel a white peppery come back on the tongue in an aftertaste way

Paired with Dominican Rhum:anejoMild-Medium
Read smoke log →
Alec Bradley Estelí shared by Ben 8.0/10
Ben
BenFeb 28, 2026 · Intermediate
Alec Bradley
Estelí

Sweet smooth creamy opening, little bit of a flower taste on the edge of the toung

Medium-Full
Read smoke log →
Cohiba Rubicon shared by Ben 8.5/10
Ben
BenFeb 27, 2026 · Intermediate
Cohiba
Rubicon

What a great cigar. Very affordable. I love it. I revisit it once more. Smooth leather earthy. Marzipan notes on the last third

Paired with Old FashionedMedium-Full
Read smoke log →
La Flor Dominicana Solis shared by Cigar AI member 9.3/10
Cigar AI memberFeb 24, 2026
La Flor Dominicana
Solis

A well put together cigar, the draw is smooth and it paired perfectly with my latte.

Paired with LattéFull
Read smoke log →
Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva shared by Ben 8.5/10
Ben
BenFeb 20, 2026 · Intermediate
Arturo Fuente
Gran Reserva

Smooth creamy love it. Beautiful retrohale.

Smoked in The Carnegie ClubMild-Medium
Open cigar profile →
E.P. Carrillo Pledge shared by Ben 6.0/10
Ben
BenFeb 20, 2026 · Intermediate
E.P. Carrillo
Pledge

Harsh, heavy, oily. Stabilize after first third. But still oily and buttery. It’s too strong for me.

Paired with Old FashionedFull
Read smoke log →
Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real shared by Ben 7.5/10
Ben
BenFeb 12, 2026 · Intermediate
Romeo y Julieta
Reserva Real

Smooth, cream. Very light. Great cigar but too light for me and almost flavor less.

Medium
Read smoke log →
Eladio Diaz Before & After shared by Ben 6.5/10
Ben
BenFeb 10, 2026 · Intermediate
Eladio Diaz
Before & After

Earth, paper, mild spicy. Not much smoke. Like it more at the third part. Turn to be more chocolate

Paired with Aged Rum or BourbonMedium-Full
Read smoke log →
Padron 1964 Anniversary Series shared by Ben 8.0/10
Ben
BenFeb 10, 2026 · Intermediate
Padron
1964 Anniversary Series

Little bit bitter at the end of the puff Clear taste, it developed beautifully on the second third. Smooth, nuts, wood

Medium-Full
Read smoke log →
My Father Blue MMXXV shared by Ben 7.5/10
Ben
BenFeb 10, 2026 · Intermediate
My Father
Blue MMXXV

Virgin puff wasn’t that good. Little bit of metal taste. But rest of puffs was really unique taste. Smooth new tastes. Earth leather taste after it stabilized. Paper notes

Medium-Full
Read smoke log →

Keep the next smoke useful.

Log the flavor, rating, and pairing while they are still fresh—then use your history when it is time to choose again.

Free journal and humidor tracking · Limited AI included · No ads · For adults 21+